Who did it better?

Since I'm finishing up this tale I thought I'd ask the question, "Who Did It Better?".  George Rozen painted the original but Steranko stepped it up a notch (or two) with the Pyramid paperback cover.  (It's interesting that the color palettes are completely opposite of one another.)  I'll always be partial to the pulp covers but I think Steranko did a great job.  So... whodunnit better?